ESSAYS
The Woman on the FloorJERSEY CITY, NJ 24 November 2009 |
|
Looking back, I can’t say she died in my arms. She didn’t. She died on the floor, half her body on the cold, linoleum tile of the supermarket aisle, half beyond the saloon-style swing door of the meat room. I was later told her name was Katherine or Kathryn or Catharine or some derivation thereof, and the idea that her friends and loved ones called her Kitty sticks out.
Actually, that’s a lie. What sticks out is the way her chest crumpled under my hands.
I may be getting ahead of myself.
***
I was a junior-going-on-senior in college, finishing a dual degree in biology and literature with concentrations in pre-medicine and creative writing, respectively, and I had just realized I am not a doctor. For most of that summer, I had killed time working in a supermarket, first in the meat room and then in produce, waiting for fall semester to start, and I was about two hours into my final shift, stocking bananas, when the store’s intercom crackled a request for anyone with medical training to please find a way to the meat room.
Now, let me be clear up front: I may have studied chemistry and physics and anatomy and physiology, all in the pursuit of human health, but I did not have medical training. I may have been a boy scout, earning merit badges in not just first aid but also lifesaving and emergency preparedness, all of which required classes lasting several hours at a time, but I did not have medical training. I may have practiced cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) on dummies and known how to procure potable water in a desert and learned how to rescue breathe and haul a nearly-drowned swimmer to shore, but I did not have medical training.
(This is probably where I should place a disclaimer like: don’t try this at home. Unless, of course, somebody needs it and you know, however vaguely, what to do, because then it might just save a life. Also: this post is not intended for instructional purposes. Be prepared. Take a course. Save a life.)
My lack of actual medical training did not stop me from dropping the bunch of bananas I was stacking on the sale display and striding toward the meat room, where I found three or four people standing in front of fluorescent-lit cold cases of pink meat in plastic wrap, all of those people huddled close together, looking down at the floor between them.
I’m sure someone asked if anyone knew CPR, but only because I’ve seen it in the movies.
Autopilot: kneeling next to the woman. She was older, in her sixties or seventies, dressed in pastels and polyester like any grandmother you’ve ever met, but what I remember is that she had no color. Not just pale, but grey. In my head the voices of track-suited doctors volunteering at the Red Cross on their off days, of green-shirted camp counselors huddled around a wooden picnic table.
This is how you perform CPR:
An acronym—ABC.
First, airway. One hand on the forehead, another under the chin, a gentle slide and lift (respectively) designed to fully open the trachea and esophagus while at the same time keeping the neck itself basically stationary in case any vertebrae are broken. This motion slacks the mouth open so you can hook a finger to sweep the throat of any obstruction. This can also trigger the gag reflex, which is why so much CPR begins with a mouthful of vomit.
But not yet.
Second, listen for breathing, ear to mouth. Unfortunately, just adjusting the airway and clearing it of obstruction can release breath, so don’t move for a moment. Hold steady, or try.
(What they don’t tell you: it’s nearly impossible to hold steady. Because you want them to breathe. You need them to breathe, and you’d breathe for them, given the chance, which you’re about to demonstrate because you’re about to—and so you’re trying not to rush but it’s so hard not to. Hence the count: one one thousand, two one thousand, three one thousand. Or Mississippi. Or hippopotami. Whatever slows you down. Whatever makes them breathe.)
One one thousand. Two one thousand.
The woman on the floor did not breathe. I would have felt it, however slow, however labored, against my ear.
With one hand, I pinched her nostrils shut. I lowered my head, pressing my lips against hers in the airtight seal I had learned, and I breathed. Hard. If it’s possible to breathe too hard, I may have. This is when some people receive that mouthful of vomit. I did not.
After that breath, I turned my head so my ear was again above her lips. I felt air escape, but nothing else—one one thousand, two one thousand—which meant her exhalation had been my breath, and she had no inspiration.
So I repeated the breath, and repeated turning my head and waiting.
Still nothing.
Third, circulation: two fingers to the neck, or the inside of the wrist. I sought her carotid artery with my index and middle fingers but felt nothing.
Every class I had ever taken, every course I had ever attended, every instructor I had ever learned anything from indicated the next action I completely ignored. By every method I had ever been taught, I was supposed to tear open her blouse, or slice it open with my pocket knife, or otherwise free her upper torso to allow her internal organs room to breathe. I did not. I know I was supposed to, and I could hear those instructions from that phantom voice in my head, but I couldn’t bring myself to do it, there in that supermarket, under those glaring lights and surrounded by people watching so intensely. I don’t know why I didn’t do it—maybe an attempt to preserve the woman’s modesty, or her dignity, or something else equally intangible and perhaps equally useless.
Regardless, the next thing I did was use my left index and middle finger to find her breastbone and then place the meat of my right palm above it. I set the meat of my left palm against the back of my right hand, interlocked my fingers, locked my elbows in place, positioned my torso so I was directly above her body, and started compressing. Ten. Again with the count: one one thousand, two one thousand, three on—
Another thing they don’t tell you: chances are you will break whomever you’re doing CPR on. The breastbone, the ribcage, whatever you want to call it: it’s not built to withstand such quick, blunt motions as the compressions CPR requires, and it will crumple under your hands. Want to know what that feels like? Imagine cracking your knuckles or your neck, initial resistance punctuated by vertebral popping but on a bigger scale, harder and more reluctantly.
I felt her chest buckle like hard wicker under my fisted, pumping hands, and I thought I broke her. I thought that if she hadn’t died before, I’d done it right then.
But: don’t stop. You can’t. They tell you not to. No matter what, you keep ten-compressing and two-breathing until either someone can relieve you or trained professionals show up, whichever comes first, with the hope that the two events are one and the same.
I tried not to stop. I tried not to pause. I don’t remember if I did. I don’t remember if feeling her chest crack under my hands stunned me hard enough I slowed.
What I remember is other people. First a friend with whom I’d grown up, a guy who’d also been in scouts, on and off, and then another man with the calm assurance of a doctor. I conceded to their direction, letting them take over. I watched them continue what I had begun until maybe I couldn’t watch any longer; I don’t know if I saw the paramedics show up.
In fact, the next thing I very specifically remember is how extraordinarily important I thought it was that I should sweep the floor of the produce room. Midway through that sweeping, a friend called to invite me to a Goo Goo Dolls concert; something finally cracked in me when she asked if something was wrong, broke like I had busted that woman’s breastbone. I felt numb, detached, took my apron off and strode through the store to find the manager, quietly thanked him for having me as part of their team over the summer but I wasn’t going to finish my shift, then walked out through automatic doors that closed behind me even as my knees buckled my ass to the hard curb in front of the store. I started to cry and couldn’t stop, couldn’t get enough breath, just gasped and fell apart into a great, slobbering fool, which is how my friend found me when she pulled up in the family minivan. She took me to her home, where my father met us.
***
It was that friend who told me that woman’s name, which she’d read a day or so later in an obituary. From as much as I later heard, paramedics had said that Kitty had a massive coronary while placing an order for a cut of tenderloin, and she’d been dead before her body hit the floor. Dead before arrival to the hospital.
I came by that information passively. It may not be fully accurate.
CPR isn’t like they tell you, nor like they portray in the media. I’d seen plenty of characters in plenty of television shows perform it for a few seconds before the victim on the floor sputtered a grateful cough and then stood to applause from surrounding onlookers. In reality, people die. Wikipedia has interesting statistics regarding CPR and its use: chest compressions must start within six minutes (so precise), and rarely result in actual revival of a patient—chest compressions, it says, are meant merely to keep blood flowing, not to restart a stopped heart. You’re not working to jumpstart the pulse but rather to be it yourself, which is why the new guidelines call for 100 compressions in a minute, more than one per second, which sends dozens of hippopotami straight out the window. In fact, the guidelines and recommendations have changed drastically since I learned it then, and were different even just a few years after that, when I took a Red Cross course to certify as a personal trainer.
***
I cling to the idea that Kitty was dead before she hit the floor, because I may have no medical training but hope that first I did no harm. I hate to think that she was clinging to life until my idiot hands broke her chest in a dozen places, piercing her heart with the jagged edges of busted ribs and a shattered sternum. I rarely think of that woman by name, in fact, just of her body, just of the object I put my hands on. I wonder if doctors have to think of the body as a mass of organs and skin and bones to protect themselves from the idea of human beings on a table because that idea is just so terrifying. It’s easier to think that, by the time I got to that woman, she was just a body that had stopped working, if only because the alternative breaks my heart like I fear I might have broken hers.
|
||
Related Posts |







Wow, Will.
I felt some empathetic terror and overwrought-ness just reading your account. The image of you collapsing onto the sidewalk right after the event is a stunning one–and so utterly human.
I feel honored to have read what you’ve just shared. Thank you.
Thanks, Kristen. I struggled with the tone and am glad I pulled it off. Even more glad to have a place to share it.
Will, I think this might be my favorite of all the things you’ve put up. Very well told.
I’ve kept my CPR and First Aid certifications valid since college, but I’ve never yet had to perform CPR on another human being. Good for you for trying, Will, and for stepping up when no one else did. You kept a reasonably level head during an emergency, which the vast majority of people seldom do.
Thanks Matt. Those certifications are so good to have; they definitely lend some confidence, be it false or earned, when you need the knowledge. It was good part of me went on auto-pilot, kind of like when you get in the zone when writing, or I imagine like guitarists hands during a song they’ve performed a thousand times.
Will,
Let me say first off: You did not ‘break her heart’ - a massive coronary means, as you say, she was already dead by the time you got to her. You did everything possible and I’m sure she would be grateful to you for attempting to give her back her breath. But more than that, I’m positive she would have been grateful that you left her clothes on. You ensured she had dignity.
I agree with you that people don’t understand the reality of CPR. I recently did a first aid course and couldn’t believe that I didn’t know you ONLY perform CPR on someone who is literally dead. For some reason I had it in my head that if someone was unconscious then maybe you should give them CPR. What a fool I felt. But again, I blame it on TV - all those shows where a couple of mouth to mouth resusitations suddenly have the person leaping back to life. It just isn’t like that in reality.
Nice piece, Will. Your empathy shone through.
Thanks, Zara. You’re right, of course. It’s funny, there’s always part of me that wants to have done more, helped more, performed better, like it’s a personal affront that life doesn’t fix itself when I’m around. I’m sure other people feel the same.
But yes, TV is definitely partly to blame. CPR was featured in this week’s The Mentalist (a cool show for anyone not yet watching); the agent on whom it was performed woke up in a hospital. But at least he didn’t come to while Robin Tunney was performing it. She counted very quickly and without thousands, as per the new guidelines, which I’m sure will soon be the old guidelines.
I have a friend who is a certified nurse/nuke med tech, who sidelines teaching CPR and first aid. He’s convinced that the American Heart Association changes it’s CPR guidelines every couple of years (from 1/15 breaths/compressions to 2/30, for instance) just so they can print and sell more copies of their book.
I hate so much to be so cynical, but I think I would totally believe that.
Seriously, though, I think what it really comes down to is fallibility. We have to accept most people aren’t going to survive an SCA, nor the CPR that might just save them. It’s probably arguable there’s no right way to do it, because there are so many different bodies and people; all we can hope is to do the best we can in the moment we have, which means I wonder if there can be any universal practice of CPR that works across the board. I think I doubt it.
Will, I love the way you write. You always capture my attention within the first few words.
Funny, I just completed a first aid course last week. I found myself going back to practicing on that dummy and counting along with you, “one one thousand, two one thousand…”
I doubt I’d be as cool and calm as you describe yourself. I’d be in a flat out panic. There’s something noble about trying save someone’s life. I’m proud of you that you tried!
****
The timing of death, like the ending of a story, gives a changed meaning to what preceded it.
-Mary Catherine Bateson, With a Daughter’s Eye, 1984
Thanks, Simone. I can’t take any credit; I really was on autopilot. Little thought, more action. Mainly because of those thousands; it’s as though they know how panicked you’re going to be, and so they decide they’re going to do some ritualistic, rote memorization to ground you. If you’re concentrating on counting and pumping and checking this pulse and that breathing and everything else, there’s a good chance you’re going to completely forget to panic until it sets in later and you, you know, break down in the parking lot.
Dude, as I said above, you totally deserve credit for remaining composed and focusing on what needed to be done instead of just panicking. That takes a pretty fair amount of fortitude.
My mom was in charge of certifying all the public health nurses for CPR. She’s never had to use it. Neither have I. Closest I’ve gotten is making out with the plastic dummy from the class. I did know a paramedic who broke a woman’s bottom rib giving her the Heimlich. She is eternally grateful. It’s good to know that the training paid off and you went into autopilot. I’m always afraid the stress of the situation will scramble my mind and I’ll forget something, or everything.
I remember thinking it was amazing how much I remembered to do, and how distracting it all was. And that’s awesome your mother did that; we definitely need such courses. Especially now, given how vastly things have changed with automatic electric defibrillators and the like. Brave new world.
I took a CPR course in high school - they had these little business cards full of instructions that you can slip into your wallet to carry around in case of the worst. That seemed like a great idea to me - not so much if they’re going to go and change the instructions, of course.
I really liked this Will - although I’m sorry that you had to go through it. It makes me want to go back and refresh my CPR knowledge so, if the moment comes, my autopilot’s ready.
Man, life should always come with cheat sheats. Be so much better that way! Ha!
Thanks for the sentiment, but if I imply I regret the experience, I don’t. I’m sorry she passed, but as many others have stated in this thread: it was her time. Truly, those five minutes were the most humbling of my entire life, and I think of them anytime someone tells me how arrogant I am, or how awesome.
Glad you liked it, though, and good luck refreshing. May you use it well should need ever be.
Will, I think you were brave. You were there and you gave it your all and no one- no one- could have asked for more.
Thanks, Marni. I appreciate it. I wouldn’t claim bravery; I like to hope anyone would have done the same. I mean, I know I shouldn’t, and I know, if that were true, no one would have been gathered around the woman when I got there because they would have been helping, but maybe I just had good auto-pilot.
I agree with what Marni said. Had you just cowered in the aisle, not responding to the call, you’d feel much worse about it than you do now, of this there is no doubt.
Also: fewer middle-aged women have heart attacks than do middle-aged men, by far I think, but when the former have them, the chance of survival is much less.
It was her time, and no amount of bodice-ripping you didn’t do would have changed that.
G
Heh. Bodice-ripping. Awesome.
And yeah, I definitely would have felt worse. Like that scene in Saving Private Ryan, when the guy just stands there while, a landing up, his comrade gets stabbed. That scene was so hard to watch.
And I didn’t know that about about the statistically-speaking. Interesting.
It takes a special person to respond to someone in need that way…and to write about the experience with such honesty and feeling. Beautiful, Will.
Thanks, Ronlyn. I’m glad you liked it. It was good to write.
Dude. Panic isn’t even an option. I so get that. While I have never attempted to save the life of anyone suffering from a massive coronary event, I’ve been in emergency situations before, and I am convinced that I am never as absolutely, perfectly rational as I am when my mind is, for all intents and purposes, completely checked-out.
In my imaginings of those types of situations, I am terrified, frozen, insane with fear or panic, etc. In the moment, in the actual situation, when the shit really goes down, I am a machine.
Let’s hear it for involuntary coping mechanisms.
Right? There are so many. And yeah, totally, it’s like the mind checks out. It’s near miraculous I remember as much as I do; I was just so concentrated on checking and bending and counting–
I think one of the reasons I remember breaking her breastbone so immediately and tactilely is that it was so completely unexpected, something not at all according to the plan in my head, the lessons I had learned and been taught. You’d think they would mention it, that they would say, look, at some point, when you’re pumping, her ribcage will buckle, and you’ll feel it happen. Then again, if someone had, that moment might not stick out like it does because I’d have been like, oh, good, breastbone broken, check another point off the process in my head, if that makes sense.
Of course, none of this addresses how one deals with such events after the fact.
For my part, I generally become exhausted and go into an emotional coma for weeks. Takes a lot of energy to suppress that much emotion. And though it helps at the time to have much of your brain switched off, it sucks that you don’t remember very well. Tough to check up on yourself, take inventory, etc. like, “Did it do the right thing?” “What exactly did I say and was that right?” “How long did it take for X to happen?”
I mean, tough to process that kind of thing where there isn’t much–at least conventionally–in the way of memories to process. You can’t even really console yourself with “what would I do differently next time?” because you’re not entirely sure what you did the first time.
Crazy stuff.
It’s true. That’s certainly one option. Mine, apparently, was to sweep the produce room floor.
Actually, I will note I tend to cry. Like, hard and uncontrollably. I need to fall completely apart. Sometimes, like then, it happens immediately. Other times it takes a while to process, or happens in increments, or even happens several times. But I tend to require some catharsis, and sometimes I only get it by actively digging so deep into emotion as to shoot out the other side.
I also know that part of the reason I try to act and speak honestly is to prevent that revisiting later. I have done lots of things solely because I knew, down the line, I would look back and wonder about it. There are a few things I regret in ways, but most of them stem from a moment of not living as honestly as I could. Way I figure it, when I look back, I know I was honest, and I meant it, and as long as I can say I tried as hard as I could, well, that’s all that can ever be asked of me.
Mileage, of course, varies.
Will, how incredibly brave - in the moment and in the telling. Raw, honest and beautiful.
I’ll echo that. Many people in this situation would have been paralyzed. I’ve taken CPR courses but am always afraid I could never retain any of the information in a crisis.
This is a powerful piece, both in terms of the way death impacts an individual–the way someone’s name and last moment of life continues to haunt you, and now us, even after she’s gone–and yet the way death is so anonymous and random, too.
Very nicely done.
Geez, Will, that’s riveting.